“The Black Mountain Music Project” sounds very formal but it really isn’t; what it really refers to is a little retreat Zeitlyn (who goes merely by Mirah on her solo efforts) and Takahashi took in Black Mountain, North Carolina, to relax and make music. Sara Marcus’s liner notes to the album are perhaps a bit academic; phrases like “culture-as-spectacle” and “revere the everyday and demystify art” abound. Fully half of the album’s 18 tracks are less than a minute and consist entirely of found sounds and instrumental noodling; again, to quote the liner notes, “walking from the back porch towards the kitchen to brew a pot of tea, Mirah might have paused for 10 seconds at a living room table, pressed Record on the minidisc recorder, and plucked a few tines of the music box.” So the album’s mission is to prove John Cage’s assertion (yes, quoted in the liner notes) correct, that the only difference between what is art and what is not is that we pay specific attention to art.
Unless you’re really into the idea of holding up the ephemeral and mundane as art, or as Marcus puts it, the idea of revering the everyday, Songs From The Black Mountain Music Project isn’t going to do much for you. Whatever Zeitlyn, Takahashi and their friends may have intended, it’s the songs that rightfully garner the attention. And as a document of the month they spent making music and hosting friends, the short snippets of passing trains and music box experiments—while perhaps more authentic and true to the life Zeitlyn and Takahashi lived for that month—pale in comparison to “Oh! September.” It’s a ramshackle production bursting at the seams with joy and energy, and really communicates the warm sense of community and camaderie that must have been that mountain retreat. In four minutes and eleven seconds, it tells a story more vivid and enjoyable than the combined three minutes and fifty one seconds of musical ephemera that is supposedly the focus of the album.
But enough with the philosophical debate. Pick up a trumpet and meet me at the back shack, baby.
