Belly
Full Moon, Empty Heart
Star (1993)
First, right off the bat: an interesting alternate-universe version of Star. I haven’t tried playing the album that way yet (mostly because I don’t actually have the b-sides mentioned), but it’d be an interesting experiment.
Most used record stores are pretty similar to each other. Sure, there’s the odd exception where the guy at the counter knows just as much—if not more—about 50s doo-wop as the latest wave of indie bands (hello, Vortex), but by and large used record stores look, smell and feel like you’ve just stepped into the mid 90s. Why this is, I don’t know for sure. Could be that there were just a lot of bad albums in the mid 90s—though that doesn’t explain why we don’t see ten of every single Linkin Park and Limp Bizkit album in the 99-cent bins of all upstanding used CD shops. Or it could be that the mid 90s were an unfortunate confluence: CDs had just become the dominant medium over casettes, and “alternative rock” had just become the dominant style on the radio, meaning the major labels were just beginning to jump aboard the bandwagon in droves.
Aside from mainstays like U2, Peter Gabriel and INXS, it seems like the used bins are full of one-hit wonders culled from the ranks of alternative radio. I thought I was the only person who’d ever heard that one song Radio Iodine put out, but damned if I don’t find at least one copy of the cursed album every time I do a thorough search of a store’s inventory. Imperial Drag, Semisonic, Failure, Hum—the list goes on and on. Some of these albums were even good; Pitchfork even took it upon themselves to dig through the bins and review a bunch of used bin repeat offenders. In that list (badly formatted though it is, thanks to the recent redesign), you’ll find Star sitting at #9 with a fairly glowing recommendation.
Just like those used record shops, everything about Star reeks of the mid 90s. The album design is all false-colour images and vaguely grunge treatments, all befitting an alterna-pop band trying to escape from the shadow of the Breeders—the second band Tanya Donnelly had to leave because she felt creatively stifled. The production sheen is very 90s; it sounds vaguely like the bastard offspring of the Pixies and Lush in that sense, dusty with noise and low-key distortion effects. This is what the early-to-mid 90s sounds like to me—exactly songs like “Slow Dog” and “Full Moon, Empty Heart.” Nothing put out now could ever sound like this and get away with it, but for a CD saved from the used bins like Star, I’ll easily make an exception.